Updated November 2026
A solar water heater for horse troughs, or a solar water trough heater for horses, is only worth buying if it keeps water above freezing on the coldest nights your barn sees. This list compares seven widely sold trough heaters by intended use, wattage, thermostat control and tank compatibility. Selection was based on manufacturer specifications, brand reputation and common owner feedback patterns. We did not test these units ourselves.
Best overall: Farm Innovators Cast Aluminum Convertible Tank De-Icer – View on Amazon
Best for large stock tanks: FHTONGE 500W Thermostatic Livestock Tank De-Icer – View on Amazon
Best for Rubbermaid tanks: Rubbermaid-compatible 1500W Deicer – View on Amazon
Best for mid-size troughs: PTFE Aluminum Horse Trough Heater 500W – View on Amazon
Best budget pick: Submersible Thermostatic Stock Tank Heater 500W – View on Amazon
Best for off-grid sun power: 200W Polycrystalline Solar Heater Panel – View on Amazon
Best for small add-on use: 30W Solar Heater with USB and DC Ports – View on Amazon
Our Top Picks
| Product | Best for | Key feature |
|---|---|---|
| Farm Innovators Cast Aluminum Convertible Tank De-Icer | Overall winter use | Floating or submersible, 1250W |
| FHTONGE 500W Thermostatic Livestock Tank De-Icer | Large capacity tanks | 9.8ft power cord |
| Rubbermaid-compatible 1500W Deicer | Rubbermaid stock tanks | Thermostatically controlled |
| PTFE Aluminum Horse Trough Heater 500W | Mid-size troughs | Fits 41 to 100 gallons |
| Submersible Thermostatic Stock Tank Heater 500W | Budget-minded owners | Built-in thermostat |
| 200W Polycrystalline Solar Heater Panel | Off-grid sun power | Adjustable temperature control |
| 30W Solar Heater with USB and DC Ports | Small add-on use | 100cm cable, overheat protection |
Farm Innovators Cast Aluminum Convertible Tank De-Icer
Floating or Submersible Livestock Heater with Chew-Proof Cord & Self-Regulating Thermostat for Dependable Winter Watering Farm Innovators Cast Aluminum Convertible Tank De-Icer, 1250 Watts
Best for: Overall winter use
Suited to owners who want one heater that works in open troughs and fixed tanks, with a self-regulating thermostat.
Pros
- Floating or submersible design
- Chew-proof cord
Cons
- Higher wattage draws more power
FHTONGE 500W Thermostatic Livestock Tank De-Icer
Cast Aluminum Water Heater, Immersion Trough, 9.8ft Power Cord, For Outside Horse Cattle Goat Poultry Wildlife Pool De-Icing FHTONGE 500W Thermostatic Livestock Tank De-Icer for Outdoor Large Capacity
Best for: Large capacity tanks
Fits barns with bigger water tanks where the 9.8ft cord gives room to position the unit away from the outlet.
Pros
- Long 9.8ft power cord
- Cast aluminum body
Cons
- Needs a grounded outlet
Rubbermaid-compatible 1500W Deicer
1500W Deicer, Thermostatically Controlled, Rubbermaid Water Trough Heater, Water Trough Heater for Livestock Submersible Stock Tank Heater Fit for rubbermaid Stock Tanks
Best for: Rubbermaid stock tanks
Made for owners running Rubbermaid-style polyethylene tanks who want strong thermostatic heat.
Pros
- High wattage output
- Thermostatically controlled
Cons
- Highest power draw on this list
PTFE Aluminum Horse Trough Heater 500W
Submersible & Thermostatic Control, PTFE Aluminum Chicken Water Horse Trough Pond Bird Bath Heater for Winter Outdoor 500W Stock Tank Water Trough Heater De-icer for 41 to 100Gal Livestock Tank
Best for: Mid-size troughs
A practical match for troughs in the 41 to 100 gallon range that need steady winter protection.
Pros
- PTFE-coated aluminum element
- Lower wattage than the 1500W unit
Cons
- Less heat for very large tanks
Submersible Thermostatic Stock Tank Heater 500W
Submersible & Thermostatic Control, Aluminum Painted PTFE Chicken Water Pond Horse Trough Bird Bath Heater for Winter Outdoor 500W Stock Tank Water Trough Heater De-icer for 41 to 100Gal Livestock Tan
Best for: Budget-minded owners
Works for owners who want a basic submersible heater for a small herd or backyard trough.
Pros
- Simple thermostat control
- Covers 41 to 100 gallons
Cons
- Fewer finish options than premium units
200W Polycrystalline Solar Heater Panel
Chicken Coop Warming, Frosted Pet and Polycrystalline Silicon, Pet Shelters and RV Travel, Camping Use Solar Heater, 200W Panel, Adjustable Temperature Control
Best for: Off-grid sun power
For owners without a nearby outlet who want to run a solar panel directly during daylight hours.
Pros
- Adjustable temperature control
- Suitable for remote placement
Cons
- Output drops on cloudy days and at night
30W Solar Heater with USB and DC Ports
Best for: Small add-on use
Better suited to small water containers or supplemental warmth than a full livestock trough.
Pros
- Overheat protection
- USB and DC ports
Cons
- Too little output for large troughs
Buying Guide
Heater Wattage and Tank Size
Match the heater’s wattage to the volume of water you need to keep from freezing. Larger tanks lose heat faster and need more power, while smaller troughs can often be managed with a lower-wattage unit. Check the tank capacity listed for each heater before you buy.
Thermostat Control
A self-regulating or thermostatically controlled heater switches on only when the water approaches freezing. This saves electricity and reduces the risk of overheating the water. Units without a thermostat can run constantly, which wastes power and may be unsafe in warmer weather.
Cord Safety and Chew Resistance
Horses and other livestock may chew on cords, so look for a chew-resistant, well-insulated power cord with enough length to reach a safe outlet. Keep all connections above the waterline and away from areas where animals can reach them. Ground-fault protection on the outlet is strongly recommended.
Mounting and Installation
Some heaters are fully submersible, while others float or mount on the tank wall. Choose the style that suits your trough shape and whether you want the heater to stay in place without shifting. Make sure the unit is designed for use in water and rated for outdoor conditions.
Power Source and Solar Limitations
Solar-powered options depend on sunlight, so they may not perform well during overcast days, short winter daylight hours or the coldest nights. If you rely on solar for water warming, plan for backup or consider an electric heater for reliable winter performance.
FAQ
Can a solar water trough heater keep a horse trough from freezing all winter?
Solar heaters can help take the chill off water on sunny days, but they may not prevent freezing during long, cold, cloudy stretches. Electric de-icers with thermostats are generally more dependable for keeping water open through the coldest weather. Many barns use a combination of both approaches.
How do I know what wattage I need for my trough?
Start with the tank capacity and the coldest temperatures your area typically sees. Larger tanks and colder climates require higher wattage to maintain open water. Choose a heater rated for your tank’s size range to avoid underpowering it.
Is it safe to leave a trough heater running in the barn?
Electric trough heaters are designed for continuous use when properly installed, but safety depends on correct wiring and protection. Use a grounded outlet with ground-fault protection, keep cords out of reach of animals and inspect the unit regularly. Unplug the heater if the cord or plug is damaged.
Do I need a thermostat on a trough heater?
A thermostat is strongly recommended because it allows the heater to run only when needed. This reduces energy use and helps prevent the water from getting too warm. Self-regulating models are a practical choice for most barns.
Can the same heater work for other livestock or poultry?
Many trough heaters are used for goats, cattle, poultry and wildlife water sources as well as horses. Check the manufacturer’s stated uses and make sure the heater is safe for the animals in your care. Keep the animals away from the heater’s cord and electrical connections.
Conclusion
If you need a dependable, thermostat-controlled heater for a large stock tank, an electric de-icer with a clear wattage and tank-size rating is the most reliable choice. Look for a model that matches your trough’s capacity and includes a chew-resistant cord for safety.
If you have a smaller setup in a sunny location and mainly want to take the edge off cold water, a solar-powered option may suit you, as long as you understand its limits on cloudy or very cold days. Choose based on tank size, climate and how much you can rely on sunlight.

